Anyone who knows me knows that I am a huge fan of Stephen Sondheim. I don't think any composer/lyricist living today even comes close to his brilliance. Nor has anyone been as frequently honored, feted and thanked for their contributions to the world of musical comedy. That is why I am so distressed at the recent bad press he has been getting for his comments on Lady Gaga's appearance on the Academy Awards. Supposedly he said, "On the Academy Awards she was a travesty. It was ridiculous as it would be from any singer who treats that music in semi-operatic style. She had no relationship to what she was singing." He added, "What people liked was her versatility." Sadly all kinds of people are vilfying Sondheim for his criticism, even attacking his personal relationships. What idiots. The man is genius and shouldn't be judged by pedestrian standards. Maybe he should have tempered his comments. But he has a right to his opinion. Perhaps in defense of Rodgers and Hammerstein's folksy themes, he felt that a large production number, glamorous Cinderella gown, and operatic rendition was a travesty. Maybe it was. It wouldn't be the first time audiences adored a travesty. But I feel certain that having worked with today's most admired singers he appreciates Lady Gaga's talent. Maybe, at 85, he's just forgotten that today creative criticism is no longer welcome, even from the world's leading expert.
Note: I have written three musicals. I can't think of a greater thrill than having a genius like Stephen Sondheim review them, even if he tore them apart it would be an honor.
No comments:
Post a Comment